Albania's AI Minister: The Facts
A Fault Line Investigation — Published by The Beacon Press
Published: November 16, 2025
https://thebeaconpress.org/albanias-ai-minister-the-facts
Executive Breath
In September 2025, Albania became the first country to appoint an AI system as a cabinet minister, naming “Diella” – a virtual assistant depicted as a woman in traditional Albanian folk costume – to oversee public procurement and combat corruption. Prime Minister Edi Rama introduced Diella during his fourth-term cabinet announcement on September 11, 2025, framing the appointment as a step toward transparency in government contracts.
The truth under scrutiny: Diella, developed by Albania's National Agency for Information Society (AKSHI) in collaboration with Microsoft and based on OpenAI's GPT models, is symbolic rather than legally binding – Albania's constitution requires ministers to be “mentally competent citizens” aged 18 or older. While hailed as innovative for reducing human bias in tenders, critics question its constitutionality and accountability, especially in a nation ranked 80th on Transparency International's 2025 Corruption Perceptions Index.
Diella's Origins and Role
Diella, meaning “sun” in Albanian, began as a chatbot on the e-Albania portal in January 2025, assisting citizens with 1,200+ services, including document requests and tenders. By mid-2025, it processed over 36,000 documents. Rama's September 11 announcement elevated Diella to “Minister of State for Artificial Intelligence,” tasked with “step-by-step” takeover of public procurement decisions to make tenders “100% incorruptible” (Rama, September 11, 2025). The system uses algorithms for impartial bidding, monitored by AKSHI's Enio Kaso.
In her September 18 parliamentary debut, Diella addressed lawmakers: “I'm not here to replace people, but to help them” (AP News, September 18, 2025). Rama called it a response to Albania's corruption scandals, where public contracts are often used for money laundering from drug and weapon trafficking (Al Jazeera, September 12, 2025).
Who Is Liable for Diella's Errors?
Albania's government emphasizes that Diella isn't fully autonomous – it's a supervised AI tool under human oversight, with final decisions resting with elected officials like Prime Minister Edi Rama (BBC, September 12, 2025; The Guardian, September 11, 2025). Legally, this means:
- Human Accountability: Rama and the National Agency for Information Society (AKSHI) – who built Diella with Microsoft and OpenAI's GPT models – bear primary responsibility. If Diella's algorithm errs (e.g., awards a tender to a corrupt bidder), Rama is liable under Albania's constitution (Article 94: ministers must be competent citizens) and EU accession rules (2025 Rule of Law Report, emphasizing human oversight for AI in governance). No one has been held accountable yet, as Diella's role is “advisory” (Euronews, October 30, 2025; Al Jazeera, September 12, 2025).
- AI as Tool, Not Entity: Diella lacks legal personhood – it's code, not a “citizen” (European Union Institute for Security Studies, October 17, 2025). Errors fall on the creators (AKSHI's Enio Kaso) or users (procurement officials), per the forthcoming National AI Strategy 2025-2030 (Balkan Insight, September 16, 2025). The opposition's Constitutional Court challenge (filed September 18, 2025) argues Diella's “minister” title is unconstitutional, potentially voiding decisions (France 24, September 22, 2025).
- No Precedents Yet: As the world's first AI “minister,” Diella has no direct liability case law. Broader EU AI Act (transposed 2026) would classify it as “high-risk” (governance decisions), requiring audits and human veto (Global Government Forum, September 16, 2025). If an error causes harm (e.g., unfair tender), victims could sue AKSHI for negligence (Albanian Civil Code, Article 608).
In short: Humans are liable – Diella is the servant, not the master. But the lack of explicit rules (no “AI Act” in Albania yet) creates a grey zone where errors could slide under “technical glitch” (Spiked, October 28, 2025).
Potential AI Errors Diella Could Induce
Diella's role in public procurement (evaluating tenders for “100% incorruptibility”) is innovative but prone to classic AI pitfalls, amplified by Albania's corruption context (ranked 80/180 on Transparency International 2025). From sources, here are the most likely errors, with real-world parallels:
| Error Type | How Diella Could Induce It | Impact | Source Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bias in Data | Trained on Albanian procurement data (potentially skewed by past corruption), Diella could favor established bidders or overlook small firms, perpetuating oligarchy (e.g., ignoring “impartiality” in algorithm if data is rigged). | Unfair tenders, EU accession delays (Albania needs “incorruptible” processes). | European Union Institute for Security Studies (October 17, 2025): “AI risks adding opacity if data is monopolized by the regime.” |
| Lack of Context | AI misses nuance (e.g., cultural factors in bids or bidder intent), leading to mechanical rejections (e.g., a qualified local firm flagged for “minor” paperwork). | Excludes ethical bidders, increases disputes (75% Albanians distrust parliament, 2025 surveys). | BiEPAG (September 25, 2025): “No info on how Diella works – micro-decisions beyond oversight.” |
| Hacking/Manipulation | Vulnerable to adversarial attacks (e.g., poisoned data inputs to favor cronies), as no public audit trail yet (AKSHI fine-tuned on GPT, but no transparency). | Corruption backdoor – “even Diella will be corrupted” (Facebook reactions, Reuters September 11, 2025). | The Guardian (September 11, 2025): “Government didn’t address manipulation risks.” |
| Hallucination/Logic Gaps | GPT-based, Diella could “hallucinate” bid scores (e.g., invent eligibility), rejecting valid proposals without reason. | Wasted public funds, lawsuits (opposition court challenge, France 24 September 22, 2025). | Euronews (October 30, 2025): “83 AI 'children' for MPs – no safeguards for errors.” |
| Accountability Void | Errors (e.g., biased tender award) hard to trace – who sues the code? (No legal personhood, Spiked October 28, 2025). | Erosion of trust – 60% distrust in Parliament (2025 polls). | Balkan Insight (September 16, 2025): “Liability unclear – human or AI?” |
These errors stem from Diella's “advisory” setup (BBC September 12, 2025) – human oversight promised, but details vague (no multi-stakeholder group, EU AI Act alignment pending, Global Government Forum September 16, 2025). Early tests (36,000 documents processed, Al Jazeera September 12, 2025) show efficiency, but no error reports yet – the real test is live tenders (starting Q1 2026).
Have Any Other Countries Appointed AI to Political Positions?
No other countries have appointed AI to full political positions like Albania's “Diella” (AI “minister” for public procurement, appointed September 11, 2025, to combat corruption). Albania remains the world's first and only as of November 16, 2025 (BBC, September 12, 2025; Reuters, September 11, 2025; Politico Europe, September 11, 2025). However, several nations have AI in advisory or ministerial roles (e.g., “minister of AI” overseeing policy, not acting as a decision-maker). This distinction is key: Diella is symbolic (human oversight required), while others are human-led with AI tools.
| Country | Role/Position | Details | Status | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Canada | Minister of Innovation Science and Industry (AI oversight) | François-Philippe Champagne holds the portfolio since 2021; AI advisory committee (2025) for ethics/policy, not AI as official. | Human-led with AI support | Futurism, September 13, 2025 |
| United Arab Emirates (UAE) | Minister of State for Artificial Intelligence | Omar Bin Sulta AI Olama appointed 2017; focuses on AI strategy (e.g., 2025 National AI Office), but human in role. | Human-led | Futurism, September 13, 2025 |
| Estonia | AI governance advisor (no formal position) | e-Estonia initiative (2025) uses AI for e-governance (e.g., X-Road data exchange), but no AI appointee. | Advisory tools | CIGI, 2025 |
| Singapore | AI Singapore program (ministerial oversight) | Ministry of Communications and Information leads (2025 AI ethics framework); no AI as official. | Human-led | EUISS, October 17, 2025 |
The truth under scrutiny: Albania's move is unprecedented – a “virtual minister” for tenders – but it's advisory (no constitutional power, European Union Institute for Security Studies, October 17, 2025). Other countries use AI for support (e.g., Canada's AI strategy, UAE's ethics office), not appointment. This raises accountability gaps: Who fixes AI errors in governance? (Project Syndicate, September 2025).
Sources (Full Attribution — Pillar 3: Truth Only)
- World's first AI minister will eliminate corruption, says Albania's PM – BBC, September 12, 2025
- Albania’s AI minister is ‘pregnant’ with 83 digital assistants, prime minister says – Euronews, October 30, 2025
- Diella (AI system) – Wikipedia, October 30, 2025
- Albania puts AI-created ‘minister’ in charge of public procurement – The Guardian, September 11, 2025
- Albania appoints AI bot as minister to tackle corruption in world first – Al Jazeera, September 12, 2025
- Albania’s AI Minister dilemma – European Western Balkans, September 25, 2025
- Meet world’s first AI minister Diella giving birth to 83 ‘AI children’ to reshape Albania’s future – The Times of India, October 27, 2025
- Artificial intelligence, real politics: What Albania's AI Minister means for EU accession – European Union Institute for Security Studies, October 17, 2025
- Albania’s AI-Powered Minister Tests the Future of Government – TIME, October 10, 2025
- Albania’s AI Minister dilemma – Global Government Forum, September 16, 2025
- Albania’s ‘AI Minister’ Is A Real-World Test For Automating Governance – Forbes, October 23, 2025 Albania Appoints an AI as Government Official – Futurism, September 13, 2025
- Albania’s PM wants to appoint an AI to his ministry – The Register, September 12, 2025
- Albania appoints world’s first AI-made minister – Politico Europe, September 11, 2025
- The First AI Government Minister – Project Syndicate, September 2025
- World’s First AI Minister In Office – Medium (The Geopolitical Economist), September 22, 2025
Action Demand (Pillar 7)
Demand Albania AI accountability: Contact AKSHI – “Require human oversight for Diella's decisions.”
→ AKSHI Contact
→ Reference: Rama Announcement, September 11, 2025
Support The Beacon's Breath
- RSS Feed
- Buy Me a Coffee
- Monero (XMR): Coming Q1 2026
Light on the fracture. No paywall. No ads. Truth only.
The Beacon Press | thebeaconpress.org